Skip to main content

Why Bespoke Engagement Rings Cost More Than The High Street

I don’t expect everyone to choose a bespoke engagement ring.

Some people want something they can walk into a shop and buy that afternoon, and there’s absolutely nothing wrong with that.

But if you’ve found yourself wondering why a handmade ring from an independent jeweller often costs more than something that appears similar on the high street, I thought it was worth explaining what actually happens behind the scenes.

Not to convince you.

Simply so you know where your money goes.

Every Ring Starts With A Conversation

Book A Consultation

I don’t have rows of engagement rings waiting in a display cabinet.

Almost every ring that leaves my workshop starts with two people telling me a little about themselves.

Sometimes they’ve saved photographs for years.

Sometimes they only know what they don’t like.

My job isn’t to steer them towards whatever happens to be in stock. It’s to listen, ask questions, and slowly work out what feels right.

That process takes time, but it usually produces a ring that couldn’t really belong to anyone else.

Contact Tom

I Make One Ring At A Time

A lot of jewellery is designed to be made as efficiently as possible.

Mine isn’t.

There are days where I spend hours on something that most people will never notice.

Softening an edge so it’s more comfortable to wear.

Adjusting the proportions by half a millimetre because the balance feels better.

Reworking a setting because I know I can make it cleaner.

Those decisions don’t appear on an invoice, but they’re a large part of what you’re paying for.

You’re Buying Years, Not Just Hours

People often ask how long a ring takes to make.

The honest answer is that you’re not just paying for the hours I spend making yours.

You’re also paying for the years it took to know how to make those hours count.

Knowing how metal moves.

Knowing when something looks right.

Knowing when to leave a texture alone instead of polishing it away.

Experience is difficult to measure, but it’s present in almost every decision.

I Want You To Come Back In Twenty Years

An engagement ring isn’t finished when it leaves the workshop.

At least, I don’t think it is.

I hope I’ll see it again.

For cleaning.

For resizing.

For a wedding band.

Perhaps one day to remodel it for the next generation.

That changes how I make things.

I’m not interested in building something that only needs to look good on the day it’s collected.

I’m interested in making something that still deserves to be worn decades from now.

Book A Consultation

Natural vs Lab Grown Diamonds Workbench Comparison
Natural and lab grown diamonds can appear identical, but differ in origin, rarity and long term value

You’re Working With The Person Making It

If you’ve ever commissioned something handmade before, you’ll know this part matters.

You’re not speaking to a salesperson who passes notes to a workshop somewhere else.

You’re speaking to the person who’s actually making your ring.

If I suggest changing the width of a band or lowering a setting, it’s because I’ve made enough rings to know how those decisions affect the finished piece.

That direct relationship is one of the things people tell me they value most.

So Why Does A Bespoke Ring Cost More?

Because it’s built differently.

Not just physically, but in the amount of thought, time and care that goes into every decision.

There are wonderful engagement rings available on the high street, and for many people they’re exactly the right choice.

But if you want something made around one person, by one maker, with the expectation that it will become part of your family’s story, the process naturally takes longer.

And I wouldn’t really want to make it any other way.

Tom McDanielson at the jeweller’s bench
Independent goldsmith Tom McDanielson filing a handmade silver jewellery piece at The Middle Green workshop in Wiltshire

About The Middle Green

I’m Tom McDanielson, the jeweller behind The Middle Green.

Every bespoke engagement ring is made from my workshop in Wiltshire, where I work directly with each client from the first conversation through to the finished piece. There isn’t a sales team, a design department or a production line. If you ask a question about your ring, you’ll be speaking to the person making it.

The process usually begins with an informal consultation, where we’ll discuss ideas, budget, gemstones and the style of ring you’re hoping to create. From there I’ll source stones, develop the design with you and handcraft your ring using traditional goldsmithing techniques.

The aim isn’t simply to make a beautiful engagement ring.

It’s to make one that feels like it was always meant to be yours.

Contact Tom

Natural vs Lab Grown Diamonds: What Should You Choose?

If you’re choosing an engagement ring today, you’ll almost certainly come across the question of natural versus lab grown diamonds. Both are real diamonds. Both are made from carbon. Both are incredibly hard, durable, and suitable for everyday wear. At first glance, they can appear almost identical. The real difference lies in where they come from, what they represent, and how you feel about wearing them.

Book a Consultation

What Is A Natural Diamond?

A natural diamond is formed deep within the earth over billions of years through immense heat and pressure before eventually being brought closer to the surface through volcanic activity.

Every natural diamond is the result of a process that cannot be replicated by time alone. It is a finite material created by nature over a timescale far beyond human experience.

For many people, that rarity and permanence form part of the appeal.

What Is A Lab Grown Diamond?

A lab grown diamond has the same chemical composition as a natural diamond but is created in a controlled environment using modern technology.

It is still a real diamond.

It is not cubic zirconia, moissanite, or an imitation stone.

To the eye, a lab grown diamond can look identical to a natural diamond.

The difference is that one was formed naturally over billions of years, while the other was manufactured in a matter of weeks.

Why Are Lab Grown Diamonds Less Expensive?

The primary reason is supply.

Natural diamonds are finite.

Lab grown diamonds can be produced whenever there is demand.

As manufacturing processes improve and production increases, prices continue to fall.

This allows buyers to purchase larger stones for the same budget.

The Question Of Value

For some people, a diamond is simply about appearance.

For others, the story behind the stone matters just as much as how it looks.

Natural diamonds remain rare because nature creates them in limited quantities.

Lab grown diamonds can be reproduced indefinitely.

As a result, natural diamonds have historically held their value more effectively, while lab grown diamonds have seen significant price reductions as production has expanded.

My View As A Goldsmith

Both natural and lab grown diamonds can be used to create beautiful engagement rings.

However, I personally favour natural diamonds.

Contact Tom today

Not because lab grown diamonds are inferior, but because I believe engagement rings should celebrate authenticity.

A natural diamond carries a story that cannot be recreated. It is a material shaped by the earth itself and formed long before any of us existed.

That feels meaningful in a way that a manufactured alternative never quite does.

If a client wants the character, rarity and history that diamonds are known for, I will usually recommend a natural stone.

Considering Alternatives?

If budget is the main concern, my preference is often not to replace a natural diamond with a lab grown version.

Instead, it can be worth exploring other beautiful natural gemstones.

Using Family Diamonds In A New Engagement Ring

Sapphires, spinels, garnets and other coloured stones each have their own character, history and identity.

Rather than choosing a manufactured version of a diamond, some clients prefer to choose a different natural gemstone entirely and celebrate what makes that material unique.

Which Should You Choose?

There is no universal right answer.

A lab grown diamond may suit someone whose priority is achieving the largest possible stone for their budget.

A natural diamond may suit someone who values rarity, geological history and the idea of wearing something that nature created over billions of years.

The best choice is the one that aligns with your priorities and the story you want your ring to tell.

Book a Consultation

At The Middle Green, every engagement ring begins with a conversation. Whether you choose a natural diamond, an heirloom stone, or an alternative gemstone, the goal remains the same: creating a piece with lasting personal significance that can be worn, lived with and eventually passed on.

FAQs

Are lab grown diamonds real diamonds?

Yes. Lab grown diamonds have the same chemical composition and hardness as natural diamonds.

Can you tell the difference between a natural and lab grown diamond?

In most cases, no. Specialist equipment is often required to identify the origin of a diamond.

Do natural diamonds hold their value better?

Historically, natural diamonds have retained value more effectively due to their limited supply, while lab grown diamond prices have generally fallen as production has increased.

Can I use a sapphire instead of a diamond for an engagement ring?

Yes. Sapphires are one of the most popular alternatives to diamonds and are available in a wide range of colours.

Can I use a family diamond in a new engagement ring?

In many cases, yes. Existing diamonds can often be incorporated into a completely new bespoke design.

How To Design An Engagement Ring Without Ruining The Surprise

First Things First

You Do Not Need To Know What You’re Doing

Most people designing an engagement ring have never bought jewellery before

So if you currently feel slightly out of your depth, that’s fairly normal

The majority of bespoke engagement rings start with:
• a rough budget
• a few screenshots
• maybe a vague idea of style
• and a lot of “I’m not really sure what I’m looking for”

That’s enough to begin

Part of my job is helping narrow things down and make the process feel manageable rather than overwhelming

Keeping The Whole Thing Secret

This is usually much easier than people expect

Most engagement rings are designed quietly through:
• messages
• emails
• short calls
• or one relaxed meeting

You do not need to disappear for mysterious full-day appointments every weekend

A lot of the process happens gradually in the background while normal life carries on

Book a consultation

I’m also very aware that people are often trying not to get caught

So communication can stay fairly discreet and low-pressure throughout (feel free to mute our WhatsApp chat)

How To Figure Out What They’ll Actually Like

Most people already have more clues than they realise

The easiest place to start is simply paying attention to what they already wear

Things like:
yellow gold or silver
• minimal or detailed
• delicate or substantial
• vintage feeling or modern
• polished or slightly worn-in

usually tell you far more than random trend articles online

If they wear the same ring every day, that’s probably a better reference point than Instagram

You can also quietly look at:
• Pinterest boards
• saved Instagram posts
• jewellery brands they already follow
• hints from friends or siblings

You are not trying to read their mind perfectly

You are just trying to build a clear direction

Ring Size Without Making It Obvious

This is the part people panic about most

Realistically, there are a few ways around it

You can:
• borrow an existing ring briefly
• ask a friend or family member carefully
• trace a ring on paper
• compare against your own fingers
• or estimate and resize afterwards

Resizing engagement rings later is extremely common

People massively overthink this part

What The Process Usually Looks Like

Most bespoke engagement rings follow a fairly simple process:

1. Initial Conversation

We talk through:
• budget
• style
• stones
• practical wearability
• general direction

Nothing formal or intimidating

2. Stone Sourcing & Design Direction

Once I understand the overall feel of the ring, I’ll source suitable stones and begin narrowing down design options

Usually this becomes much clearer surprisingly quickly

3. Design Refinement

This is where proportions, settings, band shape, texture and small details get adjusted

A lot of the important decisions here are actually about:
• comfort
• durability
• balance
• and how the ring feels to wear long term

not just how it photographs

4. Making The Ring

Once everything is approved, the ring gets made and finished by hand

This is usually the calmest part of the whole process

You’ve already done the hard bit by deciding to ask someone to marry you

The Important Thing People Forget

The proposal matters far more than tiny technical details

Years later, nobody remembers whether a claw was fractionally thicker than another one

They remember:
• how nervous you were
• where it happened
• what was said
• and how it felt opening the box

That’s the real memory

The ring simply becomes part of it afterwards

Final Thought

Most people come into this process worried they’ll get something wrong

In reality, engagement rings are rarely about perfection

Book a consultation

They’re usually about paying attention properly to somebody you love

The rest can be figured out together