Christmas is one of the busiest times of year for proposals, and it’s when I get the most messages from people who want to get the ring right but can’t ask the obvious question without giving the game away. What size are they?
The good news is that ring size is the easiest part of an engagement ring to put right. Here are the quiet ways I’d find out their ring size without asking, the tricks I’d avoid, and what to do if you’ve left it a little late for Christmas
Borrow a ring they already wear
The most reliable way to find out a ring size secretly is to borrow a ring they already wear, ideally one from their left ring finger. Pick a day they won’t miss it, bring it to me, and I can size it in a couple of minutes
If you can’t get it out of the house, draw carefully around the inside of the ring on paper, or press it into a bar of soap or some Blu Tack, and take a photo next to a ruler. It’s not as exact as the ring itself, but it gives me something real to work from
Which finger it comes from matters. Fingers aren’t all the same size, and the right hand is often slightly bigger than the left. If the only ring you can borrow is from another finger, tell me which one so we can allow for the difference
Ask someone they trust
If borrowing a ring isn’t possible, a trusted friend or family member can often find out for you. A sister, a best friend or a parent can usually ask without raising suspicion, especially at this time of year when people are buying rings as gifts anyway
The tricks that don’t work as well as people think
Wrapping string or a strip of paper around their finger while they sleep sounds clever, but it’s rarely accurate. String stretches, paper creases, and fingers swell and shrink through the day and with the temperature. Guessing from their glove size, or by comparing their hands with yours, is even less reliable
Guessing from a ring worn on a different finger or the other hand is the most common reason a ring comes back to me. If that’s all you have, it’s still useful, as long as I know where it came from
Why the style of the ring changes the size
A wide band or a comfort fit ring sits differently on the finger from a slim one, so the same finger can need a slightly different size. If you’re thinking about a chunkier design, tell me at the start and I’ll factor it in when we size the ring
If you get the size wrong, it’s not a disaster
Most rings can be resized after the proposal, usually by a size or two either way. It’s worth telling me if you’re unsure when we design the ring, because I can choose a style that’s easy to adjust later. Some designs, like full eternity rings or heavily patterned bands, are much harder to resize, so it’s better to know up front. I’ve written more about this in how much ring resizing costs, and whether every ring can be resized
Leaving it late for Christmas
A bespoke engagement ring takes around 6 to 8 weeks from design approval to the finished piece, so if you’re reading this in late November, a fully finished bespoke ring by Christmas Day is unlikely. That doesn’t mean you have to give up on proposing at Christmas
Some couples propose with the stone itself, presented in a box, and then design the setting together in the new year. Others propose with a simple placeholder ring and choose the final design as a couple. More and more people tell me they actually prefer this, because the person wearing the ring gets a say in how it looks
If you’d still like a surprise, we can start the design now and I’ll give you a set of design drawings to present on the day, with the ring following in the new year. I’ve written more about designing an engagement ring without ruining the surprise
Getting started
Whichever route you take, it starts with a relaxed conversation. You’ll be speaking to me, the person who designs and makes your ring, so we can work through the size, the stones and the timing together from the very first chat
Bespoke engagement rings start from around £1,450. You can see more of my work on the bespoke engagement rings page. If there’s a family ring or stone you’d like to use, I can also remodel inherited jewellery into an engagement ring, and once you’re engaged, I make wedding rings designed to sit alongside it
Planning a surprise proposal? Send me a message and I’ll help you work out the size
I’ve been making jewellery since I started my apprenticeship at 16, and engagement rings are now most of what I do at The Middle Green. Most of the rings that come back to me for changes have the same few problems. They aren’t badly made rings. They’re rings that weren’t quite thought through for the person wearing them every day
Here are the mistakes I see most often, and how to avoid them
1. Guessing the ring size
This is the big one, especially with a surprise proposal. People borrow a ring from the jewellery box, but it’s often worn on a different finger or the other hand, and fingers aren’t the same size on both hands
If you can, borrow a ring she wears on her left ring finger, or ask a friend or family member to find out quietly. If you’re unsure, it’s better to go slightly bigger than too small, because a ring that won’t go over the knuckle on the day isn’t the moment you want
Most plain bands can be resized later. Some designs can’t, or not easily, such as full eternity rings and stones set all the way around the band, so tell your jeweller early if the size is a guess
2. Chasing carat over cut
A bigger diamond isn’t always a better-looking one. Cut has the biggest effect on how much a diamond sparkles, and a well-cut smaller stone will often look brighter across the room than a poorly cut larger one
If budget is tight, I’d rather put the money into a good cut and a well-made setting than stretch for size. The same goes for coloured stones. A lively sapphire with good colour will always beat a bigger, dull one
3. Forgetting about the wedding band
An engagement ring is usually worn next to a wedding ring for decades, but the wedding band is often an afterthought. Some engagement rings are set so low, or have such a wide head, that a straight band won’t sit flush against them, which leaves a gap
That isn’t always a problem. A shaped or fitted wedding band can follow the line of the engagement ring perfectly. But it’s worth thinking about both rings together from the start, so the pair looks like it was meant to sit side by side
A ring has to live on a hand that works, cooks, gardens, goes to the gym and gets knocked on door frames. Very high settings catch on jumpers and hair. Very fine bands look delicate on day one but wear thin over the years and become harder to resize or repair
Stone choice matters too. Diamonds and sapphires are hard enough for daily wear. Softer or more fragile stones like opal, emerald or tanzanite can be beautiful, but they need more care and a more protective setting
The best ring is one that suits the person’s life as well as their taste. That’s a big part of what we talk about in a consultation
5. Leaving it too late
Bespoke takes time to do properly. From the first conversation through the design, the CAD, casting, setting and finishing, my bespoke rings usually take 6 to 8 weeks. Rushing any stage is where things go wrong
If you’re planning a proposal around a date, like Christmas, a birthday or a holiday, start earlier than you think you need to. If time has run out, you can still propose with a design and make the finished ring together afterwards, which many couples prefer anyway
6. Overlooking what’s already in the family
Some of the most meaningful rings I make start with a stone that’s been sitting in a drawer. A grandmother’s diamond, an old-cut stone or a ring that no longer gets worn can often be reset into something new that still carries the history
It’s always worth asking family before buying a new stone. I can look at what you have and tell you honestly what can be reused. Read more about family diamond engagement rings
Natural and lab grown diamonds can appear identical, but differ in origin, rarity and long term value
Getting it right from the start
Almost all of these come down to the same thing: talking it through before anything is made. When you work with me, you’re speaking to the person designing and making your ring, so we can cover the size, the stone, the wedding band and how it’ll be worn from the very first conversation
Bespoke engagement rings start from around £1,450, and wedding bands from £300. If you’d like to talk through an idea, you can see more of my bespoke engagement rings or book a consultation, remote or in person by appointment
Sapphires come in almost every colour except red, which is called ruby. Blue is the best known, but green, teal, yellow, pink, white and parti sapphires are all the same stone, coloured by tiny traces of other elements as they form
Are all sapphires blue?
No. Sapphire is a variety of the mineral corundum, and it can form in almost every colour. The one exception is red, which is called ruby, even though it’s the same mineral
When people say “sapphire” on its own, they usually mean blue, because blue is the colour the stone is best known for. Every other colour is sometimes called a fancy sapphire, but they’re just as hard-wearing and just as much a sapphire as the classic blue
What decides the colour is which trace elements were present as the crystal formed, and in what amounts. That’s why sapphires vary so much, even within one colour
Blue sapphires
Blue is the colour most people picture, and for good reason. It comes from traces of iron and titanium, and ranges from soft cornflower to deep royal blue. The best blues are rich without turning inky, and keep their colour in both daylight and evening light
Blue is the traditional choice for an engagement ring, but it’s also the most in demand, so a fine blue usually costs more than a green or teal of the same size
Green sapphires
Green sapphires can range from pale, slightly grey greens through mossy and olive tones to much deeper blue-green stones
I particularly like the less saturated examples. They often have a quieter, more natural appearance than the intense colour associated with traditional blue sapphire
Green also works particularly well with yellow gold. The warmth of the metal can bring out the earthy tones within the stone without overwhelming it
For someone looking for an engagement ring that feels distinctly different without being overly colourful, green sapphire is one of the first options I would consider
Green or blue sapphire?
Both are equally hard-wearing, so either is a good choice for a ring worn every day. Blue feels classic and timeless. Green feels more personal and less expected, and often gives you a larger or brighter stone for the same budget. The right one is usually the one you keep coming back to when you see them side by side
Yellow sapphires
Yellow sapphires range from light lemon shades through to rich golden yellows
Set into yellow gold, they can create a particularly warm overall appearance because the colour of the stone and metal work together rather than strongly contrasting
The recently completed ring shown here uses green and yellow sapphire together. Rather than choosing stones that match perfectly, the variation in colour is part of what gives the finished ring its character
This is also one of the advantages of choosing individual natural gemstones for a bespoke piece. The starting point can be the stones themselves rather than trying to force them into a predetermined design
Teal sapphires
Teal sapphires sit somewhere between blue and green, although there is an enormous amount of variation within the category
Some are predominantly blue with just a hint of green, while others can appear distinctly green in one type of light and more blue in another
They have become an interesting alternative to traditional blue sapphire because they retain some of its familiarity while feeling much less conventional
The exact colour is particularly important with teal sapphires, so I prefer choosing them as individual stones rather than simply specifying “teal” and expecting every sapphire to look alike
Pink sapphires
Pink sapphire can range from very pale blush tones to intense, vivid pink
They offer much of the durability of blue sapphire while producing a completely different effect in a finished ring
Paler stones can be surprisingly understated, particularly when paired with white metal, while stronger pinks naturally become much more of a focal point
As with all coloured gemstones, photographs can only tell part of the story. Saturation, brightness and subtle secondary colours can make two apparently similar pink sapphires feel very different in person
White sapphires
White sapphire is essentially sapphire with very little visible colour
It is sometimes considered as an alternative to diamond, although I think it is better viewed as a gemstone in its own right
Diamond and sapphire interact with light differently, so a white sapphire will not simply look like a less expensive diamond. Its appearance is generally softer and less fiery
For someone who actively prefers that quieter appearance, however, it can work beautifully
Parti sapphires
Parti sapphires are some of the most individual stones available
Rather than displaying one consistent colour, a parti sapphire contains distinct colour zones within the same gemstone. Green, blue and yellow combinations are particularly associated with them
How those colours appear once the stone has been cut depends on the original crystal, the orientation of the colour zoning and the choices made by the cutter
The result is that two parti sapphires are rarely identical
For bespoke jewellery, that individuality can be a real advantage. Instead of choosing a gemstone because it conforms to a conventional idea of perfection, the unusual distribution of colour can become part of the design
Thinking about a coloured sapphire? I can source stones in any colour and show you options side by side, so you can choose the one that feels right
Sapphire colour comes from trace elements present within the corundum crystal as it forms
But the chemistry of the stone is only part of what you eventually see
The appearance of a sapphire can also be affected by:
its depth of colour
saturation
the way it has been cut
colour zoning within the crystal
the type of light in which it is viewed
the surrounding metal and other gemstones
This is why I place considerably more importance on looking at the individual stone than simply working from a description on a gemstone certificate or supplier’s listing
A sapphire described as “green”, for example, could be pale sage, olive, blue-green or so dark that it appears almost black in some lighting
Choosing sapphire for an engagement ring
Sapphire is particularly well suited to engagement rings because it combines colour with very good durability
how the finished ring needs to withstand everyday wear
Sometimes the right stone is an intense blue sapphire. At other times it might be an imperfect green, a warm yellow or a parti sapphire with an unusual area of colour running directly through the centre
There is far more freedom than the traditional image of a blue sapphire engagement ring might suggest
Choosing the stone before designing the ring
With unusual sapphires, I often prefer to let the gemstone influence the design rather than beginning with a completely fixed idea of what the finished ring must look like
An unusual shape, colour transition or natural characteristic within a sapphire can become something to work with rather than something that needs hiding
That is particularly relevant to bespoke jewellery
Instead of finding a stone that approximately fits an existing ring design, the proportions of the setting can be developed specifically around the individual gemstone
The result tends to feel much more resolved because the stone and ring were considered together from the beginning
Beyond blue
Classic blue sapphire deserves its reputation, but it is only one possibility
Green, yellow, teal, pink and parti sapphires offer a much broader palette, particularly for people who want an engagement ring or piece of jewellery that feels personal without relying on an obviously unconventional design
For me, the attraction is not simply that these sapphires are different
It is that no two natural stones need to be treated in exactly the same way
If you are considering a sapphire for a bespoke engagement ring, I can source individual stones in different colours, shapes and budgets before designing the ring around the one that feels right
Have a colour in mind, or not sure yet? Send me a message and I’ll show you a few stones to compare
That is the point where there is usually enough room in the budget to make sensible choices around metal, stone and design without forcing too many compromises.
But under £1,000 is still possible.
It just needs to be a much simpler ring.
What would an engagement ring under £1,000 look like?
At that budget, I would probably be looking at something like:
a simple 9ct yellow gold band
a small centre stone
a straightforward setting
very little additional stone setting
possibly some hand engraving or another small personal detail
The important thing is not trying to make a £1,500 or £2,000 ring fit into a £1,000 budget.
I would rather simplify the design properly.
That usually gives you a better ring.
The stone probably wouldn’t be a diamond
A diamond is possible in some circumstances, particularly if it is very small, but it would not usually be where I would start.
Once you begin putting a meaningful portion of a £1,000 budget into a diamond, there is less available for the actual ring.
A coloured gemstone can make much more sense.
A small sapphire, for example, could give the ring a strong focal point without consuming the whole budget.
There are plenty of stones worth considering, although I would always choose something suitable for regular wear rather than simply picking the cheapest option.
A customer-supplied stone can make this sort of budget work particularly well.
If you already have a suitable gemstone, whether inherited, sentimental or simply something you have sourced yourself, that removes one of the biggest costs from the project.
It gives me more room to put the budget into the ring itself: enough gold, a secure setting and good proportions. That can make the difference between a compromised design and a simple ring that is properly made.
A simple bespoke engagement ring in 9ct yellow gold with a small blue gemstone, showing what can be possible around a £1,000 budget.
I would probably use 9ct gold
For this sort of budget, 9ct gold (yellow, white or rose) is probably the most useful starting point.
It gives us more room to make the band substantial enough while keeping the overall cost under control.
I would not want to save money by making the ring excessively thin.
The ring still needs to work as an engagement ring that may be worn every day for decades.
Keep the band simple
This is where I would save most of the workshop time.
A clean band with a simple setting can still feel completely individual if the proportions are right.
You do not necessarily need:
diamond-set shoulders
an elaborate gallery
multiple stones
complicated shaping
lots of decorative elements
Every additional feature adds material, stones or workshop time.
On a limited budget, I would rather spend that money making the basic ring properly.
There is still room for something personal
Simple does not have to mean generic.
One thing I would consider at this level is engraving.
A date, initials, a short phrase, a symbol or a small detail can make a very simple ring much more personal without requiring a completely different construction.
This is often where bespoke makes sense on a smaller budget.
The individuality does not necessarily have to come from adding more material.
Sometimes it comes from one decision that would not exist on an off-the-shelf ring.
Why do I normally say bespoke starts from £1,500?
Because £1,500 gives us considerably more freedom.
At that point, we can start considering:
a wider choice of gemstones
larger stones
more complex settings
additional diamonds
heavier bands
more involved handmade details
potentially platinum depending on the design
It means I can make decisions based more heavily on what suits the ring rather than constantly asking what needs to be removed to hit the budget.
That is why I use £1,500 as my normal starting point for bespoke engagement rings.
It is not an arbitrary minimum.
It is simply where I find the process becomes much more flexible.
A simpler bespoke engagement ring using a customer-supplied synthetic stone to keep the overall cost down.
What I would not do for £1,000
I would not try to make an elaborate ring cheaply.
I would not make the band unnecessarily thin to save gold.
I would not use a poor-quality stone simply because it was technically a diamond.
And I would not add lots of small details at the expense of the basic construction.
If the design somebody wants really needs £1,500 or £2,000, I would say so.
There is no benefit in forcing it.
What I would make instead
If somebody came to me with a firm £1,000 budget, I would probably start with:
9ct gold (your choice of colour).
A simple, nicely proportioned band.
One small, interesting stone.
A secure setting.
Then perhaps one engraved detail to make it theirs.
That could make a very good engagement ring.
It would not be trying to look more expensive than it is.
It would simply be a small, properly made bespoke ring.
So, can you get a bespoke engagement ring for under £1,000?
Yes.
But I would treat it as the exception rather than the standard starting point.
Most of my bespoke engagement rings begin at around £1,500 because that gives us much more freedom to make the ring properly without the budget dictating every decision.
If £1,000 is the available budget, though, there are still good options.
The answer is usually to make the ring simpler, not worse.
Every bespoke engagement ring begins with an idea. Design sketches, carefully selected diamonds and thoughtful craftsmanship all come together before the ring reaches the workshop bench.
2. Prioritising Diamond Size Over Overall Design
It’s easy to focus on carat weight.
After all, it’s the figure everyone talks about.
But a well-proportioned 1.0ct diamond will usually look far more impressive than a poorly cut 1.3ct stone.
One of the first questions I’m asked as a bespoke jeweller is:
“How long does it actually take?”
The honest answer is usually between four and eight weeks
Sometimes it’s quicker. Occasionally it takes a little longer
At The Middle Green, every engagement ring is designed and made by Tom McDanielson from his Wiltshire workshop. There isn’t a production line or a catalogue of ready-made settings waiting on a shelf. Each ring is created specifically for one person
The overall timescale depends less on the making itself and more on the decisions that happen before the workshop even comes into play
Every bespoke engagement ring begins with an idea. Design sketches, carefully selected diamonds and thoughtful craftsmanship all come together before the ring reaches the workshop bench
Step 1: The Initial Consultation
Every bespoke engagement ring starts with a conversation
Some couples arrive knowing exactly what they want
Others know how they want the ring to feel but haven’t settled on a design yet
During your consultation with Tom McDanielson, we’ll discuss:
Your lifestyle
Preferred styles
Gemstones
Metal choices
Budget
Practical considerations
There’s no pressure to make every decision in one meeting. In fact, taking a little more time at this stage almost always leads to a better ring
The aim isn’t simply to choose a design. It’s to understand what will suit you for years to come
Step 2: Designing the Ring
Once we’ve established the direction, I’ll begin developing the design
This might involve:
Hand sketches
CAD modelling
Sourcing suitable gemstones
Refining the proportions
This stage often involves a little back and forth
Small changes to the height of a setting, the width of a band or the shape of the claws can make a surprising difference to both the appearance and comfort of the finished ring
Rather than adapting a standard design, every commission is developed around the individual wearing it
Step 3: Sourcing the Perfect Stone
If we’re using a diamond or coloured gemstone that isn’t already in stock, it needs to be sourced
For many diamonds this only takes a few days
Rare gemstones, unusual cuts or specific colours can naturally take longer to find
I’d always rather spend an extra week finding the right stone than rush into buying one that isn’t quite right
The gemstone is often the centrepiece of the ring. It’s worth taking the time to choose carefully
Natural and lab grown diamonds can appear identical, but differ in origin, rarity and long term value
Step 4: Making the Ring
Once everything has been approved, the workshop begins
Depending on the design, this may include:
Casting
Hand fabrication
Soldering
Shaping
Polishing
Stone setting
Final finishing
This is where experience really matters
Every bespoke engagement ring is personally made and finished byTom McDanielson, rather than being passed between different departments or outsourced manufacturers
A ring isn’t simply assembled
Every stage influences the final result, from how securely the stone is held to how naturally the ring sits on the finger
It’s these small details that often separate a handmade ring from a mass-produced one
Step 5: Final Checks
Before any ring leaves my workshop, I personally check:
Stone security
Surface finish
Ring size
Overall balance
Comfort
The goal isn’t simply to make the ring look beautiful on collection day
It’s to create something you’ll still enjoy wearing every day, decades from now
Can It Be Made Faster?
Sometimes
If you already have a proposal date in mind, let me know as early as possible
Simple designs can occasionally be completed more quickly, depending on current workload and gemstone availability
The earlier we begin the process, the more choice you’ll have
When Should You Start?
As a general guide:
Planning to propose in two months? Now is a good time to get in touch
Planning to propose in three to six months? That’s ideal
Getting married next year? There’s plenty of time to create something special
Leaving everything until the final few weeks usually limits gemstone choices and creates unnecessary pressure for everyone involved
Why Bespoke Takes Time
A bespoke engagement ring isn’t taken from a display cabinet
Every decision is made for one person
The proportions
The stone
The fit
The finish
Those details can’t be rushed
The extra time invested throughout the process allows the finished ring to feel considered, balanced and completely individual, rather than simply chosen from a standard collection
Working Directly with the Maker
One of the advantages of choosing an independent jeweller is that you’ll work with the same person from beginning to end
From our first conversation through to handing over the finished ring, you’ll deal directly with Tom McDanielson, founder and goldsmith at The Middle Green
There are no sales teams, account managers or production departments. Just an honest conversation, thoughtful design and careful craftsmanship
If you’re considering a bespoke engagement ring and would like to explore your ideas, I’d be delighted to help. Whether you already have a clear vision or are starting with a blank sheet of paper, together we can create a ring that’s designed around your story and made to last a lifetime
Tom McDanielson is the founder and goldsmith behind The Middle Green, creating handmade bespoke engagement rings, wedding rings and heirloom jewellery from his Wiltshire workshop. Every commission is personally designed and made by Tom, combining traditional goldsmithing techniques with thoughtful, individual design to create jewellery that’s made to be worn for generations
Some people want something they can walk into a shop and buy that afternoon, and there’s absolutely nothing wrong with that.
But if you’ve found yourself wondering why a handmade ring from an independent jeweller often costs more than something that appears similar on the high street, I thought it was worth explaining what actually happens behind the scenes.
Natural and lab grown diamonds can appear identical, but differ in origin, rarity and long term value
You’re Working With The Person Making It
If you’ve ever commissioned something handmade before, you’ll know this part matters.
You’re not speaking to a salesperson who passes notes to a workshop somewhere else.
You’re speaking to the person who’s actually making your ring.
If I suggest changing the width of a band or lowering a setting, it’s because I’ve made enough rings to know how those decisions affect the finished piece.
That direct relationship is one of the things people tell me they value most.
So Why Does A Bespoke Ring Cost More?
Because it’s built differently.
Not just physically, but in the amount of thought, time and care that goes into every decision.
There are wonderful engagement rings available on the high street, and for many people they’re exactly the right choice.
But if you want something made around one person, by one maker, with the expectation that it will become part of your family’s story, the process naturally takes longer.
And I wouldn’t really want to make it any other way.
Independent goldsmith Tom McDanielson filing a handmade silver jewellery piece at The Middle Green workshop in Wiltshire
Every bespoke engagement ring is made from my workshop in Wiltshire, where I work directly with each client from the first conversation through to the finished piece. There isn’t a sales team, a design department or a production line. If you ask a question about your ring, you’ll be speaking to the person making it.
The process usually begins with an informal consultation, where we’ll discuss ideas, budget, gemstones and the style of ring you’re hoping to create. From there I’ll source stones, develop the design with you and handcraft your ring using traditional goldsmithing techniques.
The aim isn’t simply to make a beautiful engagement ring.
It’s to make one that feels like it was always meant to be yours.
There is nothing wrong with a classic diamond solitaire.
Diamonds are durable, beautiful and incredibly well suited to jewellery that is worn every day. There is a reason the traditional engagement ring has remained popular for generations.
But it isn’t compulsory.
If you’ve spent hours looking at engagement rings and everything is beginning to feel strangely similar, it might be worth looking beyond the traditional options.
Here are seven reasons your engagement ring doesn’t have to follow the usual rules.
A handmade yellow gold ring set with a natural salt and pepper diamond and turquoise accents, combining organic textures with distinctive colour.
1. It should reflect the person wearing it
An engagement ring is one of the few pieces of jewellery someone may wear every day for decades.
It seems slightly strange, then, to choose one based entirely on what an engagement ring is expected to look like.
Look at the jewellery they already wear.
Do they choose yellow gold or white metals? Delicate jewellery or heavier pieces? Clean shapes or organic forms? Colourful gemstones or something more understated?
I find this far more useful than asking what engagement ring style somebody likes.
The best engagement rings tend to feel like a natural extension of the person wearing them.
Not a piece of jewellery they’ve suddenly started wearing because they got engaged.
2. Diamond isn’t your only option
Diamond is an exceptional material for an engagement ring.
It is incredibly hard, available in a huge range of shapes and works with almost any style of setting.
But it isn’t the only gemstone worth considering.
Sapphires naturally occur in an enormous range of colours. Deep blue is the obvious one, but green, yellow and pink coloured sapphires can create completely different rings.
Rubies and spinels can also be excellent choices. Some tourmalines may be suitable depending on the design and how the ring will be worn.
The important point is that not every beautiful gemstone makes a good engagement ring.
I regularly see rings designed around a lovely stone with very little consideration for the fact it is expected to survive decades of daily wear.
Stone choice matters.
If you’re looking at an unusual gemstone, speak to somebody who understands how the finished ring will actually be worn.
3. Alternative doesn’t have to mean impractical
One of my biggest frustrations with unusual jewellery is seeing design prioritised completely over wearability.
An engagement ring still has a job to do.
It needs to survive being worn.
A ring can be asymmetric, textured, sculptural or set with an unusual gemstone while still being designed sensibly for everyday life.
The gemstone matters. The setting matters. The height of the ring matters. How exposed the stone is matters.
Even how a future wedding ring will sit alongside it is worth considering before the engagement ring is made.
Good bespoke design isn’t about ignoring practical considerations.
It is about working creatively within them.
4. You can spend your budget on what you actually care about
Traditional engagement ring shopping can become very focused on numbers.
Carat weight. Colour. Clarity. Certification.
Those things have their place, particularly when buying diamonds, but they aren’t the only measures of a good engagement ring.
Perhaps you would rather have a beautifully coloured natural sapphire.
Perhaps you prefer the warmth and character of a diamond with a little colour.
Perhaps a smaller gemstone in a heavier, more substantial handmade setting feels far more like the person wearing it.
There is no rule saying the largest possible diamond is the best use of your budget.
A bespoke ring gives you more freedom to decide where the value is for you.
A bespoke ring featuring a vivid green tsavorite, handcrafted in Wiltshire by Tom McDanielson.
5. The most personal details don’t need to be obvious
Some of my favourite details in bespoke jewellery are the ones most people will never notice.
A small design detail connected to a place, memory or shared story.
These things don’t need a lengthy explanation every time somebody notices the ring.
Their importance comes from the wearer knowing they are there.
An engagement ring can carry personal meaning without needing to announce it.
6. Personal design often ages better than trend-led design
This might sound contradictory.
Surely a classic engagement ring is less likely to date than an unusual one?
Not necessarily.
There is a difference between designing around someone’s personal taste and designing around a current trend.
Jewellery trends move just like clothing, interiors and everything else. When one particular ring style suddenly appears everywhere, there is a reasonable chance it will eventually become associated with a very specific period.
A genuinely personal ring has a different type of longevity.
The question I prefer to ask isn’t:
“Will this still be fashionable in ten years?”
It is:
“Will this still feel like the person it was made for?”
That tends to lead to much better design decisions.
7. Your engagement ring doesn’t have to look like an engagement ring
This is probably the simplest reason.
There are no engagement ring police.
You don’t need a white diamond.
You don’t need a solitaire.
You don’t need a delicate band.
You don’t need to choose platinum.
You don’t even need to begin the process knowing exactly what style of ring you want.
If you know the person you’re proposing to would look at a traditional engagement ring and say, “That’s just not me,” that is already useful information.
A bespoke engagement ring can begin with a gemstone, an inherited piece of jewellery, a photograph, a vague idea or simply a conversation about the person who will eventually wear it.
The aim isn’t to make something unusual for the sake of being different.
It is to make the right ring for one person.
Handmade platinum eternity ring featuring alternating pink sapphires and diamonds, finished with delicate milgrain detailing.
I design and make bespoke engagement rings from my Wiltshire workshop, working directly with clients from the first conversation through to the finished ring.
You don’t need a finished design before getting in touch. A few ideas, photographs or a description of the person I’m designing for is usually enough to begin.
Explore my alternative engagement rings, unique engagement rings and unusual engagement rings, or start a conversation about your own ring.
If you’re designing a bespoke engagement ring, one of the first decisions you’ll make isn’t the diamond.
It’s the metal.
Every precious metal has strengths, compromises and a different character. The best choice depends on how you live, the style you’re drawn to and how you want the ring to age over the years.
Here’s how I explain the options during a consultation.
Why Platinum Is Often the Best Metal for an Engagement Ring
Platinum is the metal I recommend most often for engagement rings.
It’s naturally white, exceptionally durable and doesn’t rely on a surface coating to keep its colour. Rather than wearing away, platinum gradually develops a soft patina that many people grow to love.
Because it’s denser than gold, it also has a reassuring weight in the hand.
Platinum is particularly well suited to:
Everyday wear
Larger diamonds
Delicate claws that need long-term strength
People who prefer a cooler white finish
Platinum has traditionally been the more expensive option, although precious metal prices fluctuate and there are periods when it can cost less than 18ct white gold. Rather than focusing purely on today’s metal price, I recommend choosing the material that best suits how you want the ring to look, wear and age.
A handmade yellow gold ring set with a natural salt and pepper diamond and turquoise accents, combining organic textures with distinctive colour.
18ct Yellow Gold
18ct yellow gold offers a rich, warm colour that has been associated with fine jewellery for centuries.
It contains 75% pure gold, making it more valuable than 9ct gold while still being strong enough for everyday wear.
It pairs especially well with:
Champagne or yellow diamonds
Vintage-inspired designs
Warm skin tones
Traditional styling
Many clients choose platinum claws with an 18ct yellow gold band to combine the warmth of gold with the durability of platinum around the diamond.
18ct White Gold
White gold provides a bright, modern appearance similar to platinum, but there is one important difference. Depending on the gold market, an 18ct white gold ring can sometimes cost more than an equivalent platinum ring. Material prices change regularly, so it’s always worth getting an up-to-date quote rather than relying on general assumptions.
White gold is usually finished with rhodium plating, which creates its crisp white appearance. Over time this coating naturally wears and may need reapplying every few years depending on wear.
Some people don’t mind this maintenance. Others prefer platinum because it remains naturally white throughout its life.
9ct Gold
9ct gold is a popular option when working to a tighter budget.
It is generally harder than 18ct gold because it contains a higher proportion of alloy metals. Hardness, however, isn’t the same as toughness or durability in a finished ring, which is why the overall design and craftsmanship remain just as important.
For many engagement rings it offers excellent value while still creating a beautiful, long-lasting piece.
Does the Metal Affect Durability?
Yes, but perhaps not in the way many people expect.
The overall design of the ring, the thickness of the band and the quality of the craftsmanship often have a greater impact on longevity than the metal alone.
A well-designed ring in 9ct gold will usually outlast a poorly designed platinum ring.
That’s why I always look at the whole piece rather than recommending a metal in isolation.
Which Metal Do I Recommend?
There isn’t a single correct answer.
For most clients:
For most engagement rings, I generally recommend platinum because it’s naturally white, durable and requires very little ongoing maintenance. That recommendation is based on how it performs over decades of wear, not simply on today’s metal prices.
18ct yellow gold is ideal if you love warmth and traditional character.
18ct white gold offers a bright modern appearance if you’re happy with occasional rhodium plating.
9ct gold is an excellent choice when balancing budget and longevity.
The right metal is the one that suits both your lifestyle and the ring you’re creating.
One thing that surprises many people is that platinum isn’t always the most expensive option. Precious metal markets move constantly, and there are times when an equivalent platinum ring can actually cost less than one made in 18ct white gold. That’s why every bespoke quote I provide is based on current metal prices rather than assumptions.
Custom yellow gold bridal set featuring a pear shaped yellow diamond and matching diamond-set wedding band
Thinking About a Bespoke Engagement Ring?
Choosing the metal is just one part of the process.
During a consultation we’ll look at your lifestyle, budget and design ideas before deciding which material is best for your ring. The aim isn’t simply to choose the most expensive option. It’s to create a ring that still feels right years from now.
If you’re choosing an engagement ring today, you’ll almost certainly come across the question of natural versus lab grown diamonds. Both are real diamonds. Both are made from carbon. Both are incredibly hard, durable, and suitable for everyday wear. At first glance, they can appear almost identical. The real difference lies in where they come from, what they represent, and how you feel about wearing them.
A natural diamond is formed deep within the earth over billions of years through immense heat and pressure before eventually being brought closer to the surface through volcanic activity.
Every natural diamond is the result of a process that cannot be replicated by time alone. It is a finite material created by nature over a timescale far beyond human experience.
For many people, that rarity and permanence form part of the appeal.
What Is A Lab Grown Diamond?
A lab grown diamond has the same chemical composition as a natural diamond but is created in a controlled environment using modern technology.
It is still a real diamond.
It is not cubic zirconia, moissanite, or an imitation stone.
To the eye, a lab grown diamond can look identical to a natural diamond.
The difference is that one was formed naturally over billions of years, while the other was manufactured in a matter of weeks.
Why Are Lab Grown Diamonds Less Expensive?
The primary reason is supply.
Natural diamonds are finite.
Lab grown diamonds can be produced whenever there is demand.
As manufacturing processes improve and production increases, prices continue to fall.
This allows buyers to purchase larger stones for the same budget.
The Question Of Value
For some people, a diamond is simply about appearance.
For others, the story behind the stone matters just as much as how it looks.
Natural diamonds remain rare because nature creates them in limited quantities.
Lab grown diamonds can be reproduced indefinitely.
As a result, natural diamonds have historically held their value more effectively, while lab grown diamonds have seen significant price reductions as production has expanded.
My View As A Goldsmith
Both natural and lab grown diamonds can be used to create beautiful engagement rings.
Sapphires, spinels, garnets and other coloured stones each have their own character, history and identity.
Rather than choosing a manufactured version of a diamond, some clients prefer to choose a different natural gemstone entirely and celebrate what makes that material unique.
Which Should You Choose?
There is no universal right answer.
A lab grown diamond may suit someone whose priority is achieving the largest possible stone for their budget.
A natural diamond may suit someone who values rarity, geological history and the idea of wearing something that nature created over billions of years.
The best choice is the one that aligns with your priorities and the story you want your ring to tell.
At The Middle Green, every engagement ring begins with a conversation. Whether you choose a natural diamond, an heirloom stone, or an alternative gemstone, the goal remains the same: creating a piece with lasting personal significance that can be worn, lived with and eventually passed on.
FAQs
Are lab grown diamonds real diamonds?
Yes. Lab grown diamonds have the same chemical composition and hardness as natural diamonds.
Can you tell the difference between a natural and lab grown diamond?
In most cases, no. Specialist equipment is often required to identify the origin of a diamond.
Do natural diamonds hold their value better?
Historically, natural diamonds have retained value more effectively due to their limited supply, while lab grown diamond prices have generally fallen as production has increased.
Can I use a sapphire instead of a diamond for an engagement ring?
Yes. Sapphires are one of the most popular alternatives to diamonds and are available in a wide range of colours.
Can I use a family diamond in a new engagement ring?
In many cases, yes. Existing diamonds can often be incorporated into a completely new bespoke design.